top of page
  • Writer's pictureCortez on the Water

St. Augustine’s Real Estate

The Shifting Sands of St. Augustine's Housing Market The real estate scene in St. Augustine and its picturesque beach area paints a tale of two markets, each with its own rhythm, influenced by the ebb and flow of economic tides.

A Buyer's Market Emerges Since the leaves began to fall in October 2022, St. Augustine's housing market has gracefully transitioned from a seller's stronghold to a buyer's haven. This shift heralds a time of generally lower prices and homes taking a leisurely stroll in the market before finding their match. The numbers speak clearly: the median sold price has taken a 9.5% dip over the year, settling at $406,666, with the impact varying across homes of different sizes. While 4-bedroom homes have seen their prices climb, their 1 to 3 and 5+ bedroom counterparts have witnessed a gentle deflation in value.

Inventory and Sales: A Balancing Act October 2023 brought a fresh breeze, with the inventory of homes up by 13.1% since September, suggesting a growing buffet of choices for buyers. Sales also saw a healthy 18.8% uptick, with a twist — most homes sold were bargained below the asking price, showcasing buyer's newfound clout at the negotiation table. Yet, homes didn't linger long, with the average sale time shrinking by a robust 24.1% to a mere 44 days.

St. Augustine Beach: A Different Story St. Augustine Beach, on the other hand, tells a different story. Here, median sold prices have risen by 7.1% to an impressive $612,500. This beach area, too, has shifted to a buyer's market, but the script is different. Two-bedroom homes have enjoyed a 12.9% appreciation, while the more spacious 5+ bedroom homes have seen their prices trimmed by 9.5%. Even as the inventory expanded by 14.6%, the actual sales plummeted by a staggering 66.7%, signaling that more homes on the market doesn't necessarily mean more sales.

Redfin's Take Redfin's analysis offers a bird's-eye view, branding St. Augustine's market as "somewhat competitive." Homes here are finding owners after about 51 days on the market, at a median price point of $450K — a 5.2% yearly increment. The current market sees homes typically closing at about 4% below asking price after about 50 days of listing.

A Complex Landscape The unfolding story in St. Augustine and St. Augustine Beach showcases a nuanced market. Buyers may find hidden gems, while sellers still have the chance to strike a good bargain, especially if they're dealing in the more sought-after 2 and 4-bedroom homes by the beach. The rising tide of inventory points to a market that's gradually favoring buyers, yet the true nature of each deal is as unique as the homes and locations themselves.

12 views0 comments


Cortez blue logo png.png
bottom of page